What is a discrepancy in a background check?
A discrepancy occurs when information identified during a background check differs from the details provided by the candidate, or when the results contain information that requires further attention.
For example, this could involve employment dates that do not match the candidate's CV, qualifications that cannot be verified, information identified during a criminal record check or a record of payment default identified through a credit check.
It is important to remember that a discrepancy does not automatically mean something is wrong. In some cases, it may simply be the result of a misunderstanding, incomplete information or details that need clarification. A discrepancy also does not necessarily mean that the candidate has deliberately provided incorrect information.
How common are discrepancies in background checks?
The likelihood of identifying a discrepancy during a background check depends partly on which checks are included. The more comprehensive the screening profile, the more information may need to be reviewed or followed up.
Statistics from one of Disa's customers show that 61.5% of 689 completed background screenings required additional attention. At the same time, 78.8% of the individual checks were classified as correct.
Discrepancies and findings requiring additional attention were most common in CV comparison checks (63.2%) and employment history and reference checks (36.8%). The corresponding figures were 8.2% for criminal record checks and 2.3% for identity verification.
How are discrepancies presented in the screening report?
Each check has a status indicator that helps employers understand the result.
If a check is marked with a yellow exclamation mark, the employer can find more information in the relevant section of the screening report. This explains what information has been identified and what may need to be followed up. A yellow indicator does not automatically mean that the candidate is unsuitable for the role. It simply highlights information that the employer may need to review and assess.
What should employers do if a discrepancy is identified?
When a background check reveals a discrepancy, it is important not to jump to conclusions. How the information should be handled depends on the nature of the discrepancy and its relevance to the role.
1. Understand the discrepancy
Some discrepancies are minor and have little relevance to the role the candidate has applied for. Others may indicate a higher level of risk, depending on the responsibilities of the position. In such cases, the employer should follow up on the discrepancy internally, in accordance with the organisation's screening policy.
2. Assess its relevance to the role
Not all discrepancies carry the same significance. Consider the responsibilities, duties and requirements of the position. Information that is relevant to one role may have little or no significance for another.
3. Give the candidate an opportunity to respond
There may be a reasonable explanation for a discrepancy. Allowing the candidate to clarify or correct information helps reduce the risk of making decisions based on misunderstandings or incomplete details.
4. Make an informed decision
Once the information has been reviewed and any relevant questions have been addressed, the employer can make an individual assessment. A discrepancy should not automatically result in a candidate being rejected.
A clear screening policy makes discrepancies easier to manage
To ensure that discrepancies are handled consistently and responsibly, it is valuable to establish clear procedures before conducting background checks.
A screening policy can help define which checks should be carried out for different roles, who is responsible for reviewing the results and how any discrepancies should be followed up.
What does GDPR say about handling discrepancies?
When a background check reveals a discrepancy, it is important to ensure that personal data is handled lawfully and responsibly. This includes processing only relevant information and restricting access to those who need it for their work.
Personal data relating to criminal offences is also subject to specific requirements under Article 10 of the GDPR. In Sweden, Disa holds authorisation from the Swedish Authority for Privacy Protection (IMY) to process such information within the conditions of its authorisation.
Want to learn more about background checks?
We help organisations develop relevant screening profiles and establish structured processes for conducting background checks and following up on the results.
Tommy Erkki
Customer Success Manager
DISA