The Importance of Verifying Valid Prescriptions

In today's employment landscape, the intersection of workplace safety, drug testing, and employee rights is becoming increasingly complex. One critical piece employers must understand is what constitutes a valid prescription. Having this knowledge is essential not only for compliance with various employment laws but also for maintaining a safe and effective work environment. Failing to properly recognize or manage issues around prescription medications can expose companies to significant risks — from workplace accidents to costly litigation. Understanding what makes a prescription valid, why it matters for employers, and how to handle prescription-related situations in the workplace is essential for maintaining compliance and safety.

A valid prescription is far more than just a doctor's note — it is a formal medical directive that must meet strict legal, medical, and regulatory standards to be recognized as legitimate. Several critical elements must be in place to ensure a prescription's validity:

• Issued by a Licensed Medical Professional - A prescription must be written by someone legally authorized to prescribe medications. This typically includes physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, dentists, and, in some cases, certain specialists depending on state laws. Prescriptions from unlicensed individuals or those acting outside their authorized scope are invalid, even if they appear genuine.
• Established Doctor-Patient Relationship - A valid prescription requires a documented, legitimate relationship between the prescriber and the patient. This relationship includes a thorough medical evaluation — such as an in-person examination or approved telehealth consultation — a review of medical history, a formal diagnosis, and a corresponding treatment plan.
• Legitimate Medical Purpose - The prescription must serve a real, medically justified purpose. Prescriptions issued for convenience, recreational use, or personal gain — without a diagnosed medical need — are unlawful and invalid.
• Complete and Accurate Documentation - Valid prescriptions must include essential details such as:

• • • The patient's full name and date of birth
      • The medication's name, strength, dosage instructions, and quantity prescribed
      • The date the prescription was issued
      • The prescriber's name, credentials, address, and signature
      • These details ensure a transparent, traceable record supporting accountability for the prescriber and the patient.

• Compliance with Federal and State Laws - Prescriptions must adhere to applicable federal regulations, particularly for controlled substances under the authority of the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA). Additionally, some states require compliance with Prescription Drug Monitoring Programs (PDMPs) or other local regulatory frameworks.

These requirements ensure that prescriptions are properly regulated, medically necessary, and legally defensible. Employers must understand these fundamentals to navigate situations involving employee prescription use, workplace drug testing, and compliance management appropriately.

Understanding what makes a prescription valid is critical for ensuring compliance, protecting workplace safety, and supporting employee rights. This is especially true when employees are taking prescribed medications that may impact their performance or show up in drug testing. Under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), individuals using medications for a documented disability are protected from discrimination. Failing to recognize a valid prescription or taking inappropriate action could expose employers to legal liability.

Prescriptions also play a significant role in drug testing programs. A valid prescription may explain the result when an employee tests positive for a substance. In these cases, a Medical Review Officer (MRO) is often involved to verify the legitimacy of the prescription and assess any potential safety concerns. This process helps employers make fair, informed decisions while maintaining privacy and avoiding assumptions.

Even when medications are legally prescribed, they may cause side effects that compromise safety in certain job functions. Employers who understand how to evaluate prescription use properly can take appropriate steps to reduce risk, such as reassessing duties or requesting medical clearance, without violating employee privacy. Handling these situations consistently and respectfully builds trust, improves communication, and reinforces a culture of compliance.

When faced with situations involving employee prescriptions—whether related to a drug test result, accommodation request, or safety concern—employers must follow a standardized and legally sound process. Properly handling these scenarios protects both organizational liability and employee rights. Key best practices include:

• Utilize a Medical Review Officer (MRO) - An MRO serves as a neutral third party who reviews prescription validity confidentially. They help determine whether a legitimate prescription explains a positive drug test and whether medication use may pose a safety risk in the workplace. This protects employers from making uninformed or biased decisions and keeps sensitive health information appropriately handled.
• Establish Clear Written Policies - Employers should develop and communicate formal policies that outline how employees can disclose prescription use, how that information will be verified, and how any potential safety concerns will be assessed. A transparent, written policy encourages compliance and protects against claims of inconsistency or discrimination.
• Request Verification Documentation (with Consent) - When an employee presents a prescription concerning a workplace issue, employers should ask for written confirmation from the prescribing provider. This request must be made with the employee's consent and should focus only on the legitimacy of the prescription—not the diagnosis.
• Evaluate Safety Based on Function, Not Diagnosis - Employers should never ask for the medical condition itself. Instead, they should assess whether the employee can safely perform essential job duties while taking the prescribed medication. For example, if a medication may cause drowsiness or delayed reaction times, evaluating its impact on safety-sensitive tasks is appropriate.
• Train HR and Management - Ongoing education for HR teams and front-line managers is essential. Training ensures that those involved in employee decisions understand how to handle prescription disclosures appropriately, avoid discriminatory behavior, and maintain compliance with federal regulations.
• Stay Current on Regulatory Changes - With evolving laws around controlled substances, telehealth, and privacy standards, employers must stay updated. Regulations at both the state and federal levels are continuously shifting—making ongoing compliance monitoring a critical part of any workplace drug and safety program.

A single prescription issue can have far-reaching consequences. Mishandling prescription validation can lead to lawsuits under the ADA, fines from regulatory bodies, workplace accidents resulting in workers' compensation claims, or damage to a company's brand and reputation. On the other hand, a well-managed process can strengthen workplace safety, reduce turnover, and position the company as a responsible, employee-centered organization.

By implementing best practices, employers can navigate prescription disclosures with confidence and consistency, minimizing legal and safety risks while reinforcing a workplace culture built on trust, transparency, and respect for employee privacy. Prescription verification should be viewed not as a burden, but as an essential part of a strong compliance and safety program that helps protect employees, strengthen operations, and maintain organizational integrity through thoughtful and professional management.

At DISA Global Solutions, we offer comprehensive support to help employers confidently manage prescription-related challenges. Our drug and alcohol testing services include access to experienced Medical Review Officers (MROs) who independently review and verify prescription validity during drug testing. We also assist with policy development, training, and compliance management to ensure your workplace remains safe, fair, and legally compliant. With DISA's expertise, you can focus on building a productive, secure environment while we handle the complexities of employee prescription management and compliance requirements.

• Random Drug Testing: A Comprehensive Guide for Employers
• What Happens When an Employee Refuses a Drug Test?
• Understanding Safety-Sensitive Positions and Their Impact on Workplace Compliance

Founded in 1986, DISA is the industry-leading provider of employee screening and compliance services. Headquartered in Houston, with more than 35 offices throughout North America and Europe, DISA’s comprehensive scope of services includes background screening, drug and alcohol testing, DOT & HR compliance, occupational health services, and I-9/E-Verify. DISA assists employers in making informed staffing decisions while building a culture of safety in their workplace.